Loyal readers noticed that for a day or so this week the blog suddenly went away, requiring a password and a wordpress account, a pound of flesh and a promise to never, ever send me your first born (that last bit is still firmly in place, so go un-tape the priority mail box and let junior out, please). That came about because someone whom I had asked to respect my privacy where my blog was concerned chose to disregard that request, read it, and was unhappy with what they found. So I shut the whole mess down to give myself some time to think about it.
While I’ve never said so publicly, I’ve silently agreed with criticisms leveled against those bloggers whose families are fodder for their blogs and who have therefore created a sort of product out of their children/marriage/relationships that means any interaction must be viewed as potential material to bring in the cash. I’m uncomfortable with that. In a way, I fear that for those who are truly earning a living as a blogger, it’s kind of like the grandparent who spends every family gathering obsessively photographing or filming it. They’ve isolated themselves behind an observational lens that separates them from the experience their family is having because they are looking through the camera, thinking about lighting and focus and how to compose a good shot. The same is true of blogging–when every interaction with your spouse, every cute thing your kids says, every moment must be viewed through the lens of the internet and how to best capture it for a post, you lose a connection to yourself.
It isn’t simple. The grandpa with the camera loves his grandkids and wants to capture every moment. The mommy blogger with the precious two year old who refuses to potty train loves her kid and wants to share the ups and downs with a larger community. Sometimes the greatest infusion of encouragement comes from saying, “Wow, I’m going through X with my kid/husband/parent and I don’t know what to do” and having someone comment that they’ve gone through the same thing, here’s what worked for them. The balancing act of blogging happens at the intersection of where blogging is good for the blogger vs. unfair to the blogged about.
I don’t blog anonymously, but I don’t include the names of my family or friends beyond what they leave in comments. During a period of time of great strife in my household, I have blogged about what kid A or kid B is up to in terms of how I am feeling and what I am going through. It was called to my attention that this wasn’t okay with the person(s) being blogged about, so I have removed some content because I agree, it might suck to find out your mom/wife/friend is blogging about you. Yet, on the other hand, where do my rights as a person who needs to talk about what I’m going through come in? That’s an easy question to answer until you add “on the internet” or “in a public, open access forum”. And if I decide that my rights don’t extend to discussing specifics of what Kid A or Kid B did or said this week or what issues I’m having in my marriage or how crazy my or someone else’s mother drives me, then does my blog cease to have any value? I would be bored by purses, dog pictures and artwork, both as a blogger and as reader.
Off the top of my head, I can make a list of people I’d prefer didn’t read my blog because I am pretty sure they’d be hurt or angry: my mother, my grandmother, my inlaws, my employers, my husband’s employer, the IOGG, the drunk biologist, the Event, Still Water, etc. It would be uncomfortable at BEST.
So, that leaves me looking at my freshly sanitized blog and wondering if this is maybe not such a good idea. If maybe it’s time to rejoin the world of the Not-Internet and keep a diary if I want to write about myself. I mean, I could say that in terms of the person who read this blog, FINE, I won’t blog about YOU, but that’s not really the issue. The issue is whether or not I can write a letter to the Whole World about anyone I want. Were I to go off and start a completely anonymous blog, I’d be writing to myself and no one else, since my only web presence to date is under my real name. Right this minute, I have issues with realtionships I’d dearly love to blog about, but I feel I can’t. I’m not sure if it’s the right way to go about sorting out my feelings. I’m not sure that the benefit to me is worth the potential harm to someone else who didn’t give me permission to hang their dirty laundry out on the web, even if it does allow me an avenue by which to sort out my feelings and interact with them more successfully in the end.
UPDATE: Or, as someone I pay to advise me pointed out, I am the Mommy, and I make the decisions. So if I say that the blog isn’t someone else’s business and they choose to read it, then reader beware. I’m getting one of those shirts that says “because I’m the Mommy, that’s why” to remind me that I spend way too much time explaining myself. Which doesn’t make the above less relevant or meaningful, it just reminds me about who is in charge around here.









